Imagine this: You’re a couple hours into a road trip, Spotify just shuffled through all of the songs three times, and the silence is deafening. You possibly find yourself on a first date after you both get through the “what do you do for a living” speech.
You then change the audio settings to your secret go to fun activity on a road trip.
The classic “Would you rather?” question has evolved over time. It is no longer exclusive to middle schoolers on a sleepover. If you want to replace the dull and monotonous small talk, this is a great way to figure out how the people in your group really express themselves beyond the limits of social norms.
Here are the facts of “Would you rather?” questions and the reason why they work, as well as the solution for questions you shouldn’t be asking.
Why Can’t We Get Enought Of Them? (The Psychology)
Good “Would you Rather?” questions draw people in instantly because there are only two possible choices for answering. One has to decide for themselves, and then they have to justify their choice. There are no explaining question-answering.
This question manipulates a person into problem solving, and also fortifies the social wall that a person has. You find out so much more about a person by asking them what they would do in a situation where they have to choose between fighting a horse sized duck, or a hundred horse sized ducks, than you do by asking them what their five year vision is.
Three Rules for Creating Good Questions
The game is played incorrectly if you ask your partner the question of whether they’d win a million dollars or if they’d want to be kicked in the shins. About great questions; there is always tension present.
1. The Agonizing Equivalency Rule
Something can be either equally awesome or equally dreadful. The perplexed and contemplative stare at the drywall or at the ceiling becomes the answer.
- Poor: Would you rather be rich or poor?
- Excellent: Would you rather have to have a pebble stuck in your shoe every day or would you rather have a constant feeling of an itch in your throat, a sneeze that can’t be expelled. (Lose-lose questions are the dumbest type of questions to ask).
2. No Loopholes
It is a game of hack and defense. Parameters are an iron bound rule. A satellite phone is an escape that exists no more; there is no way from a desert island to another by a rescue boat, what’s your ex doing on the trip, or why. You either play by the rules or you don’t play at all.
3. Read the Room
Not every question you ask your friends in a team building session is appropriate for your colleagues. You’ll want to start and determine the mood, then escalate as appropriate to the group.
The Categories (with Good Examples)
Forget about that ‘invisibility vs flight’ gross simplification. Real tiers are the following:
Tier 1- Safe Ice Breakers (aka Team Builders, First Dates)
These icebreakers won’t land you in the HR office, but they will be the catalyst for some healthy debates about logic, jobs, commutes, etc.
- Would you prefer having your dream job while commuting two hours each way? Or having a boring job while having a two-minute commute?
- Would you prefer shouting at all times or would you prefer being lethargic all the time and whispering?
- Carrying the would you rather game forward, would you prefer having unlimited free food? Or would you prefer having free global flights?
Tier 2- Deep, Existential (aka the late night game?)
- Would you rather knowing the date or the cause of your death?
- Would you prefer being the funniest or the smartest?
- How would you prefer to be without your biggest regret or to be guaranteed one of your biggest dreams coming true despite it being irreversibly guaranteed?
Tier 3 (For actual friends)
These should be strictly for your trusting friends and should be patented to make all your friends feel weird.
- Would you rather be able to taste using your fingers or sweat mayonnaise?
- Would you rather be stuck with wet socks for eternity or only shower every 30 days?
- Would you rather grow fingers for toes or toes for fingers?
The Bottom Line
Quit filling in silences with dumb weather comments. Store away three or four creative “would you rather” questions. Whenever you notice the convo coasting, toss a question in. They guarantee no traffic talk for the rest of the chat.