The struggle of data-rich, cash-strapped marketers Every marketer with access to powerful data eventually finds themselves in the same place: standing on a tightrope between what they wish they could do and what can actually afford. In the digital marketing realm, this decision usually comes down to fighting between the usual suspects and a lower-cost alternative. The Keysearch vs Ahrefs fight is the perfect case for it. You’ve got Ahrefs on the one side – the data behemoth preferred by enterprise agencies and big-time pros. And on the other, you’ve got Keysearch … the favorite of travel bloggers, niche site builders, and freelancers due to it’s relatively cheap price.
To compare these two may be something like comparing a high-end sports car to a reliable and well-oiled Volkswagen. You can hitchhike or you can travel by 747, and it will get you to the same place, but the ride is not at all the same in terms of experience, speed or cost. In this extensive review, we are not going to be bothered with the marketing nonsense and simply evaluate which tools can actually be used along with how accurate (and useful) they are. Whether you are starting out in your first affiliate site, or managing a bunch of client sites, its important to get the details right between Keysearch vs Ahrefs, if youre going to spend money on it. At the end of this article, you will know which tool is right for your objectives and budget.
The Big Picture: David and Goliath
The first step to understanding which tool is best for you is to understand the core philosophy behind each one. They are designed for entirely different users.
Ahrefs: The All-Seeing Eye
Ahrefs is meteorically and universally accepted as the gold standard in SEO data. It has one of the busiest web crawlers in all the internet, crawling and updating a massive index of backlinks and keywords. Its philosophy is “give professionals every single data point they could possibly use to reverse-engineer the success of a competitor.” It’s for power users looking for ultra-detailed reports on everything from the distribution of your anchor text to content gaps.
Keysearch: The Essentialist
Keysearch takes a different approach. You start over with nothing but the sheer amount of users, many of whom were reading who were upset at all prioritization has led to shallow and rushed development even from WordPress. It does not aim to be the largest; it aims to be the most accessible. Better UI, simplified data, and barely even any learning curve. It’s designed for the solopreneur who wants to look up a keyword, write a post, and get out.
Keyword Research: Pinpoint Accuracy and Ease of Use
The most important aspect of any SEO strategy is keyword research. If the tool will not cut at this point, it is irrelevant.
The Keysearch Experience
When it comes to Keysearch vs Ahrefs, Keysearch impressively has an upper hand in this area. The beauty of it lies in its simplicity. You’ll enter a seed keyword, and it spits out hundreds of related keywords along with a color-coded difficulty score.
Keysearch has a difficulty score (1-100) which is well known to be very accurate for low-authority websites. For example, if Keysearch shows a particular keyword as “green” (which means it’s easy) then the chances are you’re new blog could get ranked for it. It also comes with “LSI Keywords” (Latent Semantic Indexing) directly inside the dashboard allowing you to enrich your content as you go.
But Keysearch itself doesn’t have its own proprietary database of search volumes, it uses third-party data, mainly Google API. It means it’s good, but like Ahrefs — probably won’t uncover the ultra-niche, zero-volume keywords that Ahrefs does.
The Ahrefs Advantage
Ahrefs is just on a whole other level. Its “Keywords Explorer” is a beast. It gives you clickstream data, which lets you know not just how many people search for a term but how many actually click on a result. This is important because we don’t want to compete for the “zero-click” search where Google provides the answer directly on the results page.
Ahrefs also does a great job with “Parent Topics.” It organizes your keywords, and in my case shows while I may want to target “best running shoes for flat feet,” I can rank for the broader term “best running shoes” by writing an article on that also. This realization can turn your Content Strategy upside down.
Winner: Ahrefs for depth and click data; Keysearch for ease of use and easy difficulty to beat if you’ve never picked up an SEO tool before.
Backlink Analysis: The Gap Widens
Backlinks are still among the most important factors in determining a site’s rankings. In order to outcompete fellow competitors, you should be familiar with who they are linking to. This is where the affordable and higher-priced versions of the tools really differ.
Keysearch’s “Backlink Checker”
There is a backlink checker included in Keysearch, and for the $17 price tag it’s not bad. It provides you with the top referring domains to a particular domain or page. You’re able to search by do-follow vs. no-follow as well as anchor text.
But Keysearch’s backlink index is much smaller than Ahrefs’. You could be looking at a competitor in Keysearch and see that they have 50 backlinks, then Ahrefs tells you the same competitor has 500. And for simple vetting — such as seeing if a site has any authority before you reach out with a guest post idea — Keysearch works perfectly. But for a complete link-building campaign in which you want to find every broken link or unlinked mention, it’s not up to snuff.
Ahrefs’ “Site Explorer”
There is no contest here. Ahrefs arguably has the best backlink index on the planet. It’s bigger, it’s faster and it’s more up-to-date than just about anything else out there.
For agencies alone, the “Link Intersect” tool is worth the subscription price. It lets you enter up to three competitors and then compare that list to the sites linking to all of them but not to you. This would give you a pre-qualified list of outreach targets that are already linking to your niche. You receive historical information as well, to see if your competition recently made a purchase of a batch of shady links or if growth is natural.
Winner: Ahrefs, by a landslide.
Content Analysis and Competitor Tracking
Now that you have your keywords, you’ll want to both monitor performance and spy on the competition.
Keysearch’s Approach
One of the tools Keysearch offers is an “Content Assistant” tool that’s surprisingly powerful. You paste your article in the format for the tool and it will search through the top 10 results and compare them to yours. It then recommends words and phrases you should use so your content becomes more relevant. It’s a smart way to maximize posts before you hit publish.
As far as tracking goes Keysearch has a rank tracker where you can track your ranks on specific keywords. It’s dependable, daily updated and gives you a pretty graph representing your awareness. It also gives you the ability to monitor competitors to see if they are creeping up on you.
Ahrefs’ Approach
What Ahrefs does offer is a basic replacement with what it calls its “Content Explorer,” although this serves more like a search engine for content. You can look up a topic and filter results by word count, social shares and domain rating. This is amazing for unearthing up-and-coming topics that dont have many backlinks (the “low hanging fruit” of content marketing).
Ahrefs’ rank tracker is fantastic, but it can be pricey if you need to track thousands of keywords. But their “Site Audit” tool is definitely among the best. It will crawl your site searching for technical errors such as broken links, missing meta tags and slow loading pages. It will provide you a health score and to-do list of how to improve your site’s technical SEO.
Winner: Tie. Keysearch wins on on-page with the Content Assistant; Ahrefs wins on technical auditing and content analysis.
Pricing: The Determining Factor
Keysearch vs Ahrefs for most people, the battle ends here. The price gap is massive.
Keysearch Pricing
Keysearch is incredibly affordable. Monthly plans begin at around $17 (even “less” with annual discounts), and with it you gain access to virtually every features. The caps are generous — you can run hundreds of searches each day and track dozens of keywords.
This falls squarely in the “no-brainer” price range for a new blogger or side-hustler. If it enables you to write just one or two ranking articles a year, well, this thing pays for itself.
Ahrefs Pricing
Ahrefs is a super premium SaaS product. Plans start at $99 per month for the “Lite” tier, and prices rapidly rise if you need more data or users. In what seems to be a relatively recent move, Ahrefs’ credit-based pricing model bills you specifically for accessing various reports and options, which makes it even more pricey when you’re using the tool heavily.
That being said, Ahrefs still provides “Ahrefs Webmaster Tools” (AWT) for free. This provides you restricted use of Site Explorer and Site Audit for your own verified sites. It’s such a generous offering, you’ll actually be able to check in on your own site health for free here (you won’t be able to do competitor research though).
Winner: Keysearch for value. Ahrefs is an investment; Keysearch is a steal.
User Interface and Learning Curve
So how practical is it to use these tools?
- Keysearch: It feels like Keysearch was created by a blogger, specifically bloggers. The menu is straightforward: Keyword Research, Explorer, Competitive Analysis, Rank Tracking. No secret sub-menus or anything to decipher. A complete beginner can watch a quick 5 minute tutorial and understand 80{732148ffa8296296f56a7ee965d4eb697269acbcd5c9e7dccb547ab3910d18ea} of the tool. The Green (easy) and Red (hard) color coding system is easy to read and no satisfying.
- Ahrefs: Ahrefs is dense. Open a report and you’re met with dozens of columns, filters, graphs. To a pro, this is paradise. To a beginner, it’s paralysis. Although Ahrefs has made nice updates to its UI and even offers a really cool academy with free courses, it however comes with some steep learning curves. In order to make sense of the data, you also need to be familiar with SEO foundations such as Domain Rating (DR), URL Rating (UR) and Traffic Value.
Winner: Keysearch for newbies; Ahrefs for data geeks.
Final Judgement: Who Should Get What?
It’s not about what tool is better msm in a vacuum, it’s where in you overall course of growth either or fits.
Choose Keysearch If:
- You’re new to intermediate blogger. You don’t need enterprise data, you just want to find low-competition keywords to write about.
- You have a limited budget. Bad business to spend $100+ a month on a tool and your site only making $50. Keysearch also gives you the benefit of keeping your overheads low.
- You think about content, not links. If your plan is “write quality articles and twiddle my thumbs” — Keysearch will get you there.
- You want simplicity. You want to log in, spend 10 minutes finding a topic and then get back to writing.
Choose Ahrefs If:
- You are an SEO agency or individual. You can be a more judgment Cost Management of client funds, you need the most accurate information to support decision making.
- Link building is your priority. You are proactively reaching out, to build broken links or do Digital PR.
- You are operating in a cutthroat niche. In niches such as finance and insurance, the “low-hanging fruit” keywords are already taken. To identify the small fissures in your competitors’ armor, you require Ahrefs.
- You have the budget. If you’re already making a bunch of money with your site, then more often than not, reinvesting in Ahrefs will give that growth an extra kick.
Conclusion
Ultimately, both of these things absolutely kill it. Keysearch is the tool that democratizes SEO, bringing you power to access keyword data for a cost of a few cups of coffee. Ahrefs is the edge that the industry needs in terms of insights and values that would LITERALLY build you million dollar businesses!
My advice? Start off with a Keysearch subscription if you’re new at this. It will last you ages. As your site grows and your need to answer questions that Keysearch cannot answer —questions like, “Who linked to my competitor yesterday?” or “How many subjects to sub-folders in this folder? or “What is the load value of this sub-folder (insert)? —then graduate to Ahrefs. In the meantime, keep your money in your pocket and concentrate on making good content.
Read Next: