The emotional wreckage that follows the failure of a marriage is required to be so much total devastation, due to infidelity. For the vast majority, there is now only one way forward: messy divorce, with lengthy hearings over property and custody. But in a few states, there’s another legal route to explore: a lawsuit against the third party who interfered with the marriage. The legal term or cause of action is called “alienation of affection.”
This article will describe this interesting variety of suit, highlight the handful of remaining alienation of affection states, and indicate what is involved in bringing such an action. We will cover the law, what you need to show in your case, and why it is best to seek professional legal aid.
Alienation of Affection Lawsuit: What Is It?
An alienation of affection claim is a tort action claims, when following separation or divorce; a third party wrongfully interfered in the marriage. Simply put, it gives a spouse the right to sue the lover of their partner. The resulting lawsuits are often referred to as “heart balm” torts, intended to remedy emotional pain and loss of a marriage.
At the heart of this cause of action is not adultery per se, but rather defendant’s malicious conduct in having an affair with plaintiff or less bringing about that one spouse lost affection for another. It is intended to keep the marital relationship free from outside influence.
These laws are holdovers from English common law, when wives were regarded as their husbands’ property. Men only could originally sue for alienation of affection. The law came to change, permitting either spouse to make a claim. But the idea has largely been abandoned and most states have eliminated these torts as outdated and subject to abuse.
The Last Alienation of Affection States
Most of the country has repealed heart balm laws. At this point, very few jurisdictions still accept cause of action. The primary states with alienation of affection laws are:
- North Carolina: By a wide margin this is both the best-known and most active state for these lawsuits. North Carolina still dominates headlines with alienation of affection cases, where people have won multi-million dollar judgments.
- Mississippi: This state still allows these kinds of claims, which enable spouses to sue for damages from people who interfere with the marriage.
- South Dakota: More rare than it is in North Carolina, but alienation of affection is still considered a legitimate legal claim in South Dakota.
- Utah: The state allows these lawsuits under its law, but with more a specific set of legal standards and so are not litigated as frequently as in other states.
- Hawaii: Hawaii acknowledges the tort, but has unique circumstances and case law that define how these cases are interpreted.
- New Mexico: You can sue a third party for breaking up your marriage in New Mexico, completing the list rounding out which states do allow such claims and don’t.
Illinois repealed its law in 2016, and other states may have particular statute of limitations or restrictions that could affect the viability of a claim.
When You Need to Prove Uplift of the Trade Secret There are three things you have to prove when seeking damages.
You cannot win an alienation of affection lawsuit simply by proving that your spouse cheated on you. In order for the plaintiff (the person who was deserted) to get such a divorce, s/he needs to prove three things to the court:
You Experienced A Real Marriage With Love And Affection
(1) “In order to show that you were happily married… and it was not a marriage of convenience, [you] have to… overcome the defendant with regard to the man’s early testimony.” If they were already unhappy or the marriage was already broken, then it’s much more difficult to persuade a judge that ‘Hey, you’re the one who did this!’” Evidence may include photos, statements from family and friends who witnessed the union, and your own personal communications describing the love you share.
Debtor Acted Willfully to Maliciously Cause Loss of Affection
The second thing is you have to show that the defendant acted with wrongful and malicious intention towards bringing about an alienation of your spouse’s affection. “Malicious” in this instance doesn’t mean malicious as in having evil intent. It might just indicate any misconduct that the defendant realized or should have recognized would harm the marriage. This is usually the hardest part to prove. Defendant’s negligence must be a proximate and controlling cause of the loss of affection, not merely a contributing factor.
The Affection and the Love Were Gone setOpen.
Finally, you have to prove that what the defendant did also resulted in a loss of love and affection between you two – for example, causing your marriage to fall apart or forcing separation. This requires a showing of the defendant’s interference as a direct cause of the termination of the marital relationship.
Adultery is strong evidence but not necessary. The claim may be established even where there was no sexual intercourse, if the defendant’s conduct (such as ongoing manipulation or false charges) was intended to wreck the marital tie.
Potential Damages in an Alienation of Affection Lawsuit
If a plaintiff prevails on their case, they can recover two kinds of damages.
- Compensatory Damages: These are the ones that are supposed to compensate for the damages you have, in fact, incurred. This can cover loss of “consortium,” which means the companionship a person receives from their spouse, “emotional distress” (mental torture) or mental anguish, and damage to reputation. “Arimony” also can include economic losses — for example, the earnings the unfaithful spouse should have made to contribute to the household.
- Punitive Damages: A court may award punitive damages in cases where the defendant’s action was especially heinous or repugnant. This money is not intended to make the plaintiff whole, but rather to punish the defendant and warn against such conduct in the future. Punitive damages have been reduced in some big cases — but not low enough to make the system impossible to game.
“I’m cheating on my wife, but here’s how I can avoid the legal consequences” Defenses To an Alienation of Affection Claim
There are several potential defenses to a claim of alienation of affection. One common defense is that the marriage was already in distress before they got involved. Proving that the couple was unhappy prior to your relationship with the defendant, were already separated or did not truly love each other will undermine an argument that it was the affair that led to the break down.
Another defence is that the accused was unaware that the individual with whom they were involved with was married. Finally, that the actions of the defendant were not the dominating cause for the separation.
Consulting a Legal Professional
Alienation of affection claims are complicated, emotional and very fact specific to the laws in one the few states that still allow them. The time within which the action must be commenced is usually very short — three years from the alienating act.
If you feel your marriage was ended because of the intervention of a third party; and you live in an alienation of affection state, it becomes very important that you consult with an attorney right away. An experienced family lawyer can review the details of your case, inform you of your rights and let you know if have a solid claim. They can assist you collecting the necessary evidence and guide you through the arduous legal and emotional journey ahead. In these cases, it’s not about getting back at the person; it’s about attaining justice for the immeasurable loss of a marital relationship.