Legendary establishments dwell in several locations within New York City, properly laying claim to the title of serving some of the best pizza in the world. The NYC pizza repertoire is endless, featuring methods from the classic foldable New York slices, wood-fired pies, Neapolitan creations, and crispy Sicilian squares.
Tourists and locals alike need to be in the know about the tastiest places to grab a slice. With NYC’s longtime pizzerias exhibiting pizza culture, prestige, and of course, excellent quality pizza, here are the recommended stops in the city.
Top 5 Pizzerias in NYC
1. Joe’s Pizza

When thinking about classic New York style square pizza, Joe’s Pizza is one of the Top 5 Pizzerias in NYC, in fact its one of the safest bet.
Speaking to the city’s classic pie institutions, Joe’s never disappoints with the tastiness of its foldable thin crust with the right amount of mozzarella and tomato. A classic for over 45 years, it’s so beloved through NYC’s best and biggest, as well as its regular folk.
Why People Love It
- Classic NYC style pizza
- Excellent crust
- Speedy service
- Mouth-watering plain cheese slices.
Best For
- Those experiencing NYC for the first time
- Plenty of slice options in a hurry
- New Yorkers with a deep love of classic pizza.
2. Song’ E Napule
For the most delicious among the Top 5 Pizzerias in NYC, a trip to Song’ E Napule is mandatory for a great slice of Neapolitan pizza.
The wood-fired oven in the restaurants open kitchen means you get to watch the pizza every so slowly come together from the super soft and chewy crust, and the rich tomato and mozzarella flown all the way in from Napoli, Italy.
Popular among pizza lovers, the Margherita and Diavola pizzas are a must try when visiting.
Why People Love It
- Naples-style pizza
- Imported Italian spices
- Fermented dough to perfection
- Welcoming Italian vibe
Best For
- A romantic sundown .
- Dinner
- Lovers of Italian food
- Fans of Neapolitan pizza
L’Industrie Pizzeria
L’Industrie was the place to be for pizza lovers .. It is a very popular Pizza destination in New York.
Located in n Williamsburg, Brooklyn, it is a blend of the burrata that is a famous slice that has exploded online and has made its way to Top Pizza lists in New York.
So why do people love the burrata at L’Industrie?
Well, a crispy yet airy slice that specializes in trendy pizza offerings at L’Industrie
Best For:
- Foodies
- Pizza Destinations
- Pizza that is Instagram ready
- Pizza destinations in Brooklyn
Mama’s TOO!
Mama’s TOO! made news with epic pizza and for being one of the best place to get pizza in the world.
The list of hashtags feature places Mrs. TOO has also earned a place with the famous Cacio e Pepe, a slice that has garnered fans for being crispy, thick, and a square slice.
Great for
- Specialty pieces
- Viral food
Pat’s Kitchen
One of the oldest pizza restaurants in New York.
First opened in 1933, coals fired at Patsy’s provide pizze with smoky flavor and a crust with char. Before the widespread of contemporary pizza styles, Patsy’s helped set part of New York City’s pizza tradition.
Why People Love It
- The foundation of New York City’s pizza history
- Coal oven flavor
- Individual Italian American pizza tradition
- Crust that is thin and crispy
- Longing to eat coal fired pizza
- Pizza tradition lovers
What People Love About New York Pizza
- Pizzas that have foldable and thin crust
- The right balance of sauce and high-gluten dough
- Crust that has a good dough consistency and a high temperature
- The taste of the dough improves with the water of New York
Final Thoughts on the Top 5 Pizzerias in NYC
There are many pizza places in New York City, and they all have a pizza style that stands out the most.
- For a classic slice of New York the destination is Joe’s.
- For a slice of Neapolitan pizza the destination is Song’ E Napule.
- For a trendy and gourmet slice of New York pizza, go to L’Industrie Pizzeria.
- For a viral rectangular slice of New York pizza go to Mama’s TOO!
- For a fun, historical, and tasty experience of coal fired pizza, visit Patsy’s Pizzeria.
Many of the most memorable pizza moments can be had at the different pizza shops of New York, and the city deserves all the praise it receives for its pizza.
Read Next: