When an injury takes place at work and nobody is around to see it, that doesn’t necessarily mean you’ve got a weak claim. What makes it weak is when you don’t document anything and everything – late reporting, failing to take photographs, neglecting to see a doctor who can draw a line from the injury to the job site. If you approach the aftermath of an incident like you’re studying a crime scene, the lack of a witness ceases to be your problem.
Report it before doubt can form
Notify your boss right away. Text messages, emails, and written notes are better than words. They show your boss that you wanted to immediately report the accident. You can’t always trust your boss to remember your conversation. They may forget, they may be absent, or they may not want to remember. Having a physical record of your report makes it impossible for the company to lie and say you never told them about your accident.
Build the physical record
Begin storing as much evidence in relation to the incident as soon as it happens. Before you’ve even left the scene, take a couple pictures of any obvious injuries and the environment in which the injury occurred. Afterwards, return to the location of the incident and take pictures if possible of everything including defective equipment, damaged rungs, missing mats, and safety warnings. Did the wet floor come from a leaking machine? Take a picture of the machine. Was a jammed machine the source of the injury? Photograph the machine.
Take photos of anything you think might have contributed to the incident. Do this quickly, as many companies have cleanup crews that are told to clear up right after an incident.
Also, check whether your workplace has surveillance cameras that may have recorded the event. While you likely don’t have the right to access these records yourself, you can send an official notice requesting that the footage be preserved before it’s overwritten. You can also request footage from prior to the incident showing you entering the area as proof that you were on the scene. This can help confirm your location and timeline if the workers compensation claim lawyers you consult later need to establish your presence in the area.
Get medical attention the same day
Getting to a doctor within the first 24 hours is important for this reason in particular: the clinical notes will outline exactly how the injury occurred when you can still remember. So if you see a doctor the following morning, and they write ‘patient reports shoulder injury sustained while lifting at work,’ they have officially tied the injury to the workplace event in your medical records. This gets used as evidence. If you leave it three days, or present after the pain has significantly increased, the other side can argue that the injury occurred elsewhere.
Muscle strains, soft tissue damage, and repetitive movement injuries resulting from body stressing account for a significant portion of these injury claims. Many of these cases occur when you’re working alone and no one else is around to witness the incident. They are also the most commonly challenged claims, as symptoms can be seemingly minor and subtle at first.
Keep a symptom record from day one
You should start documenting how the injury impacts your daily life. This does not have to be in fluent medical lingo; in fact, it is better if it is not. Use simple language and stick to the same level of detail with each entry. “Couldn’t sleep because of shoulder pain. Couldn’t lift my coffee pot at home with my right hand in the morning. Missed son’s football game.” That sort of note, made consistently throughout the weeks or months that you are dealing with your injury, will ensure that your memory of your pain and limitations is as vivid and accurate as possible.
Courts and insurance companies give these notes significant weight because they are difficult to replicate believably. A symptom diary that begins on the day of the incident and continues for weeks or months looks a lot different from one that stops and starts or that seems to have been prepared all in one go.
When the employer or insurer pushes back
If your employer challenges the claim, or the insurer disputes the evidence of causation, then the records you have established are what you will rely on. Liability determinations in respect of unwitnessed claims generally come down to whose version is more credible – and paper, not memory, is what credibility is based upon.
Don’t forget about indirect witnesses either. The colleague who saw you limping at the end of the shift, the person who overheard you telling the first aider you were in pain, the supervisor who received your text – none of these people witnessed the accident but they can all vouch for the sequence of events.
If a dispute does arise, the process isn’t so straightforward. Experienced lawyers can identify the evidentiary weaknesses in your case and advise how to best present the evidence you have when an employer or insurer calls the validity of an unwitnessed claim into question.
The absence of a witness doesn’t mean the absence of a case. It means that you have to build a stronger paper trail than someone who had three people standing next to them. It’s a higher bar, but it is one that you can clear.
Read Next: